I can't lift the curse from the Eye of Paleth. The Eyes were crafted by Human Priests, so you'll have to go to Stormwind to find someone who can help you. Speak with Archbishop Benedictus. He is head of the Cathedral of Light in Stormwind. He can help.
I hope, for your sake.
An Eye of Paleth. But this one has seen much sorrow...it must have been witness to a terrible, terrible tragedy.
Let me cleanse it, for the Eyes were created to shine bright, and their powers can be quite dangerous if tainted like this one.